TechQuiz Question 3: Nullable boxing

Why does Foo<int?> throw an exception?

   1:  static void Foo<T>() where T : new()
   2:  {
   3:      T t = new T();
   4:      Console.WriteLine("ToString: " + t.ToString()); 
   5:      Console.WriteLine("GetHashCode: " + t.GetHashCode()); 
   6:      Console.WriteLine("Equals: " + t.Equals(t)); 
   7:      Console.WriteLine("GetType: " + t.GetType());
   8:  }
  10:  public void Main()
  11:  {
  12:      Foo<int>();
  13:      Foo<int?>(); // Exception thrown
  14:  }


int? is a nullable type. T t = new T(); returns a Nullable<int> with a value of 
null. If we have a look at the definition of Nullable<T> we find the following:

   1:  [Serializable]
   2:  public struct Nullable<T> where T : struct
   3:  {
   4:      public Nullable(T value);
   6:      public static explicit operator T(Nullable<T> value);
   7:      public static implicit operator Nullable<T>(T value);
   9:      public bool HasValue { get; }
  10:      public T Value { get; }
  12:      public override bool Equals(object other);
  13:      public override int GetHashCode();
  14:      public T GetValueOrDefault();
  15:      public T GetValueOrDefault(T defaultValue);
  16:      public override string ToString();
  17:  }

As you can see, Nullable<T> overrides ToString, GetHashCode and Equals. Calling these methods on a nullable type is save will give you a nice result.

But GetType is another story. GetType only exists on the base class Object and cannot be overridden. When calling GetType on a Nullable<T>, your item is boxed to Object.

   1:  int i = 123;
   2:  // The following line boxes i.
   3:  object o = i;  

If you have a Nullable<T> with a value of null and you box it to object you get null 
back. Think of it like having a null value being boxed to a null reference. And calling GetType() on null gives you an exception!

Wouter de Kort works as a lead architect and consultant. He helps organizations stay on the cutting edge of software development. Wouter focuses on DevOps. He loves solving complex problems and helping other developers to grow. Wouter authored the book DevOps on the Microsoft stack and a couple of other books. Wouter is a Microsoft MVP and an ALM Ranger. You can find him on Twitter (@wouterdekort), on his blog at and at the various conferences where Wouter speaks.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Post comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.